Digg/shelholtz
Flickr/shelholtz
Facebook/Shel Holtz
Linkedin/shelholtz
Twitter/shel
YouTube/shelholtz
Del.icio.us/shelholtz
GMail/Shel Holtz
Technorati/shelholtz
MyBlogLog/shelholtz
Utterz/shel
§ Subscribe
§ Utterz
§ Podcast
- For Immediate Release
A weekly podcast for professional communicators from Shel Holtz, ABC and Neville Hobson, ABC.
Podcast Feed
Vote for FIR
§ PR Search
§ Places
- Shel's link blog
- Blogs I read
- Holtz Communication + Technology
- IABC
- Ragan Communications
- Society for New Communications Research
§ Dead Trees
- How to Do Everything with Podcasting
by Shel Holtz with Neville Hobson
- Blogging for Business
by Shel Holtz and Ted Demopoulos
- Corporate Conversations
by Shel Holtz
- Public Relations on the Net
by Shel Holtz
§ License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons License.
Friday, July 29, 2005
Are we reduced to only one voice?
One of the arguments I keep hearing for using blogs for just about everything from marketing to press releases is that they are written in a natural, authentic, human voice. There seems to be an unspoken ancillary statement that says: No other voice is as good as the natural, authentic, human voice.
Huh.
My favorite writer is Gabriel Garcia Marquez, who writes in lyrical, magical prose that makes me jealous every time I read him. Why can’t I put words together like he can? He’s not using complex words or complex styles. He just has the ability to create music when he strings words together. But it’s not conversational by any stretch of the imagination. Anything wrong with that?
If you’ve never read William Goldman’s screenplay for “Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid,” do yourself a favor and pick up a copy. You’ve never read such entertaining stage direction. Remember the scene, near the beginning, where Butch and Logan fight for control of the Hole-in-the-Wall Gang? Goldman’s direction instructs Butch to deliver “the most aesthetically exquisite kick in the balls in the history of modern American cinema.” Isn’t that great?
What about the inverted pyramid? Is there never an appropriate use for a solid news story any more? Should the Pulitzer organization just eliminate the newswriting category altogether and replace it with blogs?
How about poetry? No! It’s not natural, authentic, human! Take it away!
In fact, all of these styles of writing are human, and authenticity does not derive solely from a converational tone. Humans have created many styles of writing that employ many different kinds of voice. There are appropriate times for each. Let’s use them all.